Peter Steward's Web Site

   

Home Page Music Reviews Book Reviews Biography My Writing Sign Guestbook Contact Me

Main Links

My Biography

Who I am and details of  my life from birth to now.

 

Music Links

An index to all my music including CD and concert reviews and general writing

 

Diary

I have written a diary over the past 37 years. You can view entries by using  this link

 

General Writing

An index page to my writing. my novels and my poetry

 

University Work

My dissertation and other work for my MA degree.

 

My Travels

Places I have visited over 30 years of travelling

 

Site Index

Details and links to everything on my site

 

Peter on Twitter 
Peter on Facebook
View My Guestbook     
My Amazon Reviews
Free music - Best of 2009

 

 

 

 

 

Gone to Earth


Fact File


Released 1977
Label Polydor
Catalogue Number 2442-148
Producer Barclay James Harvest/Davie Rohl
Recorded when: 1977
Recorded where: Strawberry Studios, Stockport

Track Listing


Track Title Time Written By Rating
1 Hymn John Lees 6.50
2 Love is Like A Violin John Lees 6.75
3 Friend of Mine Les Holroyd 6.50
4 Poor Man's Moody Blues John Lees 7.50
5 Hard Hearted Woman Les Holroyd 6.75
6 Sea of Tranquility Wooly Woolstenholme 7.00
7 Spirit on the Water Les Holroyd 6.75
8 Leper's Song John Lees 6.50
9 Taking Me Higher Les Holroyd 6.50
Total 60.75


Average Rating 6.75

Composer Songs Time Total Points Average
John Lees 4 27.25 6.81
Wooly Wolstenholme 1 7.00 7.00
Les Holroyd 4 26.50 6.62

Personal Review

Gone to Earth is generally looked upon as one of the best of BJH's albums. I have mixed feelings and some reservations about it, however.

The songs are solid without being exceptional, although the overall feel is one of reasonable togetherness.

Poor Man's Moody Blues is correctly and undeniably a BJH classic. Many also believe Hymn to be one of the most powerful songs written by John Lees. Here I have to disagree. I find it a slightly turgid and monotonous piece and certainly not one of his best.

The band's move away from classically inspired rock is once again shown by the fact that Wooly Woolstenholme contributed only one song.

Over the years I have felt that one of the band's weaknesses has always been an insistence that Messrs Holroyd and Lees should contribute an equal number of songs. This has often backfired and led to some weaker filler material.

Whilst saying that the album doesn't have any filler tracks there are some slightly less impressive pieces that for me prevent Gone to Earth from being a classic BJH album.

Return to Barclay James Harvest Discogrophy page